A court record keeper changes a murder convict’s age in the trial record from 19 to 38, so that he looks old enough for a premature-release scheme. The District Judge lets her off with one stopped increment. The Administrative Judge of the High Court enhances that to dismissal. Sixteen years later, in Seema Sharma v. High Court of Judicature at Allahabad, the Allahabad High Court has refused to interfere. Altering a judicial record, the Court said, is a direct interference with the administration of justice and deserves no leniency.
Case at a glance
- Case: Seema Sharma v. High Court of Judicature at Allahabad through R.G. and others, Writ-A No. 71889 of 2010
- Bench: Justice Anish Kumar Gupta, Allahabad High Court
- Order dated: 2 November 2026
- Rules: U.P. Subordinate Court Staff (Punishment and Appeal) Rules, 1976; Article 226 of the Constitution
- Result: Writ petition dismissed; dismissal from service upheld
The facts
The petitioner joined the Muzaffarnagar judgeship as a paid apprentice on 13 September 1978. She was regularised as a Junior Clerk in 1983 and promoted to Assistant Record Keeper in 1985. From 17 November 1998 to 2 March 2001 she was the Assistant Record Keeper of the Civil Court, Muzaffarnagar.
In the record room lay the file of Sessions Trial No. 98 of 1977. The accused, Juber, had been convicted on 21 November 1978 for offences including Section 302 read with Section 149 IPC and sentenced to life imprisonment. His statement under Section 313 CrPC recorded his age as 19 years.
According to the respondents, a scheme of 26 January 2000 allowed the release of prisoners who had crossed 60 years of age, and the age was taken from the Section 313 statement. Applications for copies of that statement were made in July 2000. On 13 September 2000, the petitioner answered a questionnaire and certified Juber’s age at the time of the statement as 38 years. The record itself now showed a cutting: 19 had become 38.
The disciplinary proceedings
- Charges (18 February 2005): manipulating the age in the Section 313 statement from 19 to 38, and issuing a certificate wrongly showing the age as 38.
- Inquiry: nine witnesses were examined and cross-examined by the petitioner. She admitted issuing the answer of 13 September 2000. The inquiry officer found the cutting proved, and held that she either made it herself or had it made through someone else with an ulterior motive. Both charges were held proved.
- District Judge (17 September 2009): after a show-cause notice and a personal hearing, stoppage of one increment for two years under Rule 4(d) of the 1976 Rules.
- Administrative Judge (4 October 2010): after a notice for enhancement dated 9 July 2010 and her reply of 6 August 2010, the punishment was enhanced to dismissal from service and her appeal was dismissed.
What the petitioner argued
- She was on leave for parts of the year 2000, and others also held charge of the record room.
- The record had travelled to the High Court, the Supreme Court and the copying sections, so nobody could say when the cutting was made.
- No handwriting expert was examined, and there was no specific finding that she alone made the change.
- She had since retired, and sought reinstatement with consequential benefits.
What the High Court administration argued
- The age stood at 19 from 1978. There was no reason for anyone to alter it until the release scheme of 2000.
- The alteration therefore happened between 26 January 2000 and 13 September 2000.
- From 6 July 2000 to 13 September 2000 the petitioner was in charge of the record and was not on leave.
- The inquiry followed procedure, and findings of fact are not open to re-examination under Article 226.
What the Court held
1. She had a fair hearing
She received the charge-sheet, replied to it and cross-examined the witnesses. Her demand for the original charge-sheet made no difference.
2. The record was in her charge when it was altered
The relevant period was 6 July 2000 to 13 September 2000. She was undisputedly in charge of the record then and was not on leave. The age was changed from 19 to 38 so that Juber could claim the benefit of the scheme.
3. The enhancement was proper
The District Judge had taken a lenient view. The appellate authority issued a show-cause notice, considered her reply and then enhanced the punishment. The Court found no fault in that course.
4. Article 226 is not an appeal on facts
The inquiry officer, the disciplinary authority and the appellate authority had all recorded the same findings. A writ court does not re-assess that evidence or sit in appeal over it.
5. No leniency for tampering with a judicial record
Manipulating the age of an accused in a court record is serious misconduct. It interferes directly with the administration of justice, and no lenient view can be taken.
Why it matters
- For court staff and government employees: an appellate authority can enhance a punishment, provided it first gives a show-cause notice and considers the reply.
- For service lawyers: a challenge built on “others also had access” or “no handwriting expert” will rarely succeed in writ jurisdiction once concurrent findings place the record in the employee’s charge during the relevant period.
- For everyone: the custodian of a judicial record is answerable for what happens to it while it is in her charge.