Can a State acquire village land in a Scheduled Area for a private company’s mine if the village Gram Sabhas have already said no? In Bibol Toppo and Others v. State of Odisha and Others, the Supreme Court held that the prior consent of the Gram Sabha under Section 41(3) of the 2013 land acquisition Act is mandatory. The acquisition for a cement company’s mining project in Sundergarh district was set aside, though the State may start afresh in accordance with law.
Case at a glance
- Case: Bibol Toppo and Others v. State of Odisha and Others, Civil Appeal No. 8294 of 2026
- Citation: 2026 INSC 1244
- Bench: Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Satish Chandra Sharma (judgment by Justice Sharma)
- Decided: 18 November 2026
- From: Orissa High Court at Cuttack, W.P.(C) No. 31638/2022, judgment dated 6 September 2024
- Result: Appeal allowed; the acquisition, the related notifications and orders, and the High Court judgment set aside; fresh acquisition in accordance with law is not barred
The facts
The appellants live in three villages in Sundergarh district, Odisha: Kukuda, Bihabandha and Lanjiberna. A mining lease had been granted to M/s Dalmia Cements Bharat Limited, respondent no. 7, and the company asked the State to acquire surface rights over agricultural land for the mining project (paras 2 and 3). It is “the admitted position that the land in question falls in the Scheduled Area of Sundergarh District of Odisha” (para 36).
The village bodies refused. The Court records that resolutions passed on 26.01.2020 rejected the proposal (paras 4 and 41). The State went ahead regardless. It issued a fresh notification under Section 4(1) (para 5), three preliminary notifications under Section 11 in July 2021 (para 8), and, after the Collector rejected all objections, a notification under Section 19 on 3 November 2021 (para 9). The villagers went to the High Court, which dismissed their writ petition on 6 September 2024.
What the Supreme Court held
1. The consent requirement is mandatory
Section 41(3), reproduced in para 36, requires “the prior consent of the concerned Gram Sabha or the Panchayats or the autonomous District Councils” for acquisition in Scheduled Areas, and says this applies “in all cases of land acquisition in such areas, including acquisition in case of urgency”. The Court held: “the requirement of Section 41(3) of the Act is mandatory in nature” (para 39).
2. Why the Court read it that way
The Court tied the provision to the constitutional scheme: “The Fifth Schedule of the Constitution is meant to confer enhanced protection to the lands falling in Scheduled Areas” (para 42). It also relied on the old rule that where a thing is to be done in a set way, “it must be done in that manner alone, or not at all” (para 42).
3. Consent cannot be taken later
The High Court’s approach would have allowed consent to be sought during the acquisition. The Supreme Court rejected it: “the proposition that consent can be taken at all stages of acquisition is erroneous”, because it “defeats the whole purpose of “prior” consent” (para 33).
4. No consent was shown here
The Court noted that “both the Gram Sabha(s) had expressly rejected the proposal at the threshold” (para 41). The Odisha Rules require this consent on Form M under Rule 41, and the Court found: “there is no such material on record” (para 41). On the separate consent of the affected families, it found “there is no material to show that consent has been obtained in Form J” (para 33).
5. The mine was for a private company
The Court looked at the real purpose of the acquisition. “The determining factor is the purpose for which land is proposed to be acquired” (para 26). The land had been “exclusively leased to the company for conducting mining activity till 2040” (para 25), and “the acquisition was made at the instance of and for the exclusive purpose of mining by respondent no. 7” (para 27).
6. The order
“The acquisition, along with the relevant notifications, orders etc., is hereby set aside” and “The impugned judgment is also set aside” (para 58). The decision “shall not operate as an embargo in initiating fresh land acquisition process” in accordance with law and the Court’s findings (para 59).
The law in short
- Section 41(3) of the 2013 Act (RFCTLARR): in Scheduled Areas, prior consent of the Gram Sabha (or, where none exists, the Panchayats or autonomous District Councils) must be obtained before a notification is issued. Held mandatory.
- Fifth Schedule to the Constitution: gives protection to Scheduled Areas; the Court used it to explain why the consent rule is strict (para 42).
- Odisha Rules, Rule 41: consent is recorded on Form M. Its absence on the record counted against the State (para 41).
- Sections 4, 11 and 19: the notification of a proposed acquisition, the preliminary notification, and the final declaration. Consent comes before all of them.
Why it matters
- For villagers in Scheduled Areas: a Gram Sabha resolution refusing consent is a legal obstacle, not a formality. Keep copies of every resolution and the meeting record.
- For companies and acquiring authorities: obtain and file the consent before the first notification. Consent obtained later does not cure the defect.
- For lawyers: check the record for Form M, and plead the point against the notifications under Sections 11 and 19 as well as the Section 4 stage.
- For students and judiciary exam candidates: note the test the Court applied, that a provision can be mandatory even without an express penalty, and read it with the Fifth Schedule.
