Skip to content
Thursday, 19 November 2026 Judgments, law jobs and study notes, written by a practising advocate
Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 · Chapter X: Of Examination Of Witnesses

Section 141 BSA: Judge to decide as to admissibility of evidence

Corresponding IEA
Section 136 IEA

Bare Act text

(1) When either party proposes to give evidence of any fact, the Judge may ask the party proposing to give the evidence in what manner the alleged fact, if proved, would be relevant; and the Judge shall admit the evidence if he thinks that the fact, if proved, would be relevant, and not otherwise.

(2) If the fact proposed to be proved is one of which evidence is admissible only upon proof of some other fact, such last mentioned fact must be proved before evidence is given of the fact first mentioned, unless the party undertakes to give proof of such fact, and the Court is satisfied with such undertaking.

(3) If the relevancy of one alleged fact depends upon another alleged fact being first proved, the Judge may, in his discretion, either permit evidence of the first fact to be given before the second fact is proved, or require evidence to be given of the second fact before evidence is given of the first fact.

Illustrations.

(a) It is proposed to prove a statement about a relevant fact by a person alleged to be dead, which statement is relevant under section 26. The fact that the person is dead must be proved by the person proposing to prove the statement, before evidence is given of the statement.

(b) It is proposed to prove, by a copy, the contents of a document said to be lost. The fact that the original is lost must be proved by the person proposing to produce the copy, before the copy is produced.

(c) A is accused of receiving stolen property knowing it to have been stolen. It is proposed to prove that he denied the possession of the property. The relevancy of the denial depends on the identity of the property. The Court may, in its discretion, either require the property to be identified before the denial of the possession is proved, or permit the denial of the possession to be proved before the property is identified.

(d) It is proposed to prove a fact A which is said to have been the cause or effect of a fact in issue. There are several intermediate facts B, C and D which must be shown to exist before the fact A can be regarded as the cause or effect of the fact in issue. The Court may either permit A to be proved before B, C or D is proved, or may require proof of B, C and D before permitting proof of A.

Text of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (Act No. 47 of 2023), in force from 1 July 2024. Source: India Code, Government of India.

In simple words

The Judge may ask a party proposing to give evidence how the fact would be relevant, and admits it only if he thinks it would be relevant if proved. Where a fact is admissible only upon proof of another fact, that other fact must be proved first unless the Court accepts an undertaking to prove it. Where relevancy of one fact depends on another, the Judge may decide which is proved first.

Chapter X: Of Examination Of Witnesses

  1. 140 Order of production and examination of witnesses
  2. 141 Judge to decide as to admissibility of evidence
  3. 142 Examination of witnesses
  4. 143 Order of examinations
  5. 144 Cross examination of person called to produce a document
  6. 145 Witnesses to character
  7. 146 Leading questions
  8. 147 Evidence as to matters in writing
  9. 148 Cross examination as to previous statements in writing
  10. 149 Questions lawful in cross examination
  11. 150 When witness to be compelled to answer
  12. 151 Court to decide when question shall be asked and when witness compelled to answer
  13. 152 Question not to be asked without reasonable grounds
  14. 153 Procedure of Court in case of question being asked without reasonable grounds
  15. 154 Indecent and scandalous questions
  16. 155 Questions intended to insult or annoy
  17. 156 Exclusion of evidence to contradict answers to questions testing veracity
  18. 157 Question by party to his own witness
  19. 158 Impeaching credit of witness
  20. 159 Questions tending to corroborate evidence of relevant fact, admissible
  21. 160 Former statements of witness may be proved to corroborate later testimony as to same fact
  22. 161 What matters may be proved in connection with proved statement relevant under section 26 or 27
  23. 162 Refreshing memory
  24. 163 Testimony to facts stated in document mentioned in section 162
  25. 164 Right of adverse party as to writing used to refresh memory
  26. 165 Production of documents
  27. 166 Giving, as evidence, of document called for and produced on notice
  28. 167 Using, as evidence, of document production of which was refused on notice
  29. 168 Judge's power to put questions or order production