Skip to content
Friday, 20 November 2026 Judgments, law jobs and study notes, written by a practising advocate
Supreme Court

Mesne Profits: Ignoring a Witness’s Admission on Local Rent Raises a Substantial Question of Law, Says Supreme Court (Bharat Bhushan Jain v. Goodyear India)

A landlord wins possession and then spends decades fighting over how much the tenant must pay for staying on. In Bharat Bhushan Jain (Dead) through LRs v. M/s Goodyear India Ltd., a suit filed in 1990 reached the Supreme Court on the amount of mesne profits alone. The Court held that when a first appellate court ignores material evidence, such as the tenant’s own witness admitting the local rent, that omission is a substantial question of law, and the High Court can correct it in a second appeal.

Read the judgment (PDF) →

Advertisement

Case at a glance

  • Case: Bharat Bhushan Jain (Dead) through LRs and Others v. M/s Goodyear India Ltd. and Another, Civil Appeal Nos. 9668-9669 of 2013
  • Citation: 2026 INSC 1240
  • Bench: Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice N.V. Anjaria (judgment by Justice Mishra)
  • Decided: 18 November 2026
  • From: Delhi High Court, common judgment dated 11 August 2011 in RSA Nos. 186 and 187 of 2010
  • Result: Appeals dismissed; the High Court’s mesne profits rates and interest upheld

The facts

The owners let their premises at Ansari Road, Daryaganj, New Delhi, to the respondent company. The tenancy ended on 31 December 1989, and in 1990 the owners sued for possession and for mesne profits of Rs. 1,47,500 per month (para 2). On 22 December 1998 the Trial Court decreed possession and, by a preliminary decree under Order XX Rule 12 CPC, ordered a separate inquiry into mesne profits (para 3). The tenant’s appeals failed up to the Supreme Court, and the possession decree became final in 2001 (para 10).

Only the money was left. In the inquiry the Trial Court fixed mesne profits at Rs. 22 per sq. ft. per month for the ground floor and Rs. 11 for the mezzanine, with 15% interest, largely relying on the rent of a nearby bank’s premises (paras 5 and 11). The First Appellate Court set this aside as “unsupported by material evidence and … speculative and presumptuous” and fixed mesne profits on the admitted rent (para 6). In second appeals, the High Court found that the First Appellate Court had overlooked an admission by the tenant’s own witness, who had said that local rents at termination ranged from Rs. 5 to Rs. 8 per sq. ft. per month. It fixed Rs. 7 (ground floor) and Rs. 5 (mezzanine) with simple interest at 7.5% a year, reduced to 6% if paid within two months (para 8, para 13).

What the Supreme Court held

1. No rigid formula for mesne profits

Mesne profits compensate the owner for wrongful occupation. The Court said their assessment “is not governed by any rigid or inflexible formula” (para 10). The court looks at the nature and location of the property, the prevailing rent and the evidence. An appellate court interferes only where the finding is manifestly arbitrary, unsupported by the record or based on a legal error. The Court relied on Martin and Harris Private Limited v. Rajendra Mehta, (2022) 8 SCC 527.

2. The comparison with the bank premises was rightly doubted

The suit premises were in an older building and were used as a godown, while the bank’s premises were in a 1972 building used for banking. There was no valuation report or evidence of comparable construction (para 12). The two could not simply be equated.

3. Ignoring a material admission is a substantial question of law

The First Appellate Court had ignored the tenant’s own witness on the local rent range. The Supreme Court agreed that failing to consider a material piece of evidence raised a substantial question of law, which the High Court was right to address under Section 100 CPC (paras 8 and 13).

4. The High Court’s rate was balanced, not arbitrary

The High Court did not treat the admission as conclusive. It treated it as “an important circumstance forming part of the evidentiary record” and fixed rates inside the range the witness gave, without relying on the bank comparison (para 14). The Supreme Court found “neither perversity in the findings recorded nor any misapplication of the governing legal principles” (para 15).

5. Interest goes with mesne profits

“Interest” was held to be “an integral component of mesne profits”, and the High Court’s 7.5% simple interest, reducible to 6% on timely payment, was left undisturbed (para 16). Citing the long history of the case, the Court said it was better to give the litigation finality (para 17).

The law in short

  • Section 2(12) CPC defines mesne profits as the profits the person in wrongful possession actually received, or might with ordinary diligence have received, together with interest on such profits, but excluding profits due to his own improvements. (The judgment does not cite this section; it is given here for background.)
  • Order XX Rule 12 CPC: in a suit for possession and mesne profits, the court passes a decree for possession and directs an inquiry into mesne profits. This is why the amount is decided after the possession decree.
  • Section 100 CPC: a second appeal lies only on a substantial question of law. Here, ignoring material evidence was treated as one.

Why it matters

  • For landlords: do not rely on one comparable property alone. Lead evidence on the local rent range, and use the tenant’s own witnesses and documents.
  • For tenants: an admission by your own witness about the market rent can fix the figure against you. Prepare witnesses with this in mind.
  • For lawyers in appeal: to reach a second appeal, frame the point as a substantial question of law, such as a finding that ignores material evidence, and not as a plain disagreement on facts.
  • For students and AIBE: remember Order XX Rule 12 (preliminary decree, then inquiry), the definition in Section 2(12), and that interest forms part of mesne profits.

Source

Advertisement