Skip to content
Friday, 20 November 2026 Judgments, law jobs and study notes, written by a practising advocate
Supreme Court

Civil Judge Exams: Supreme Court Cuts Three-Year Practice Rule to One Year, Adds Training and Clerkship (Bhumika Trust v. Union of India)

In May 2025 the Supreme Court brought back the rule that a law graduate needs three years of practice at the Bar before taking the Civil Judge (Junior Division) exam. On 21 August 2026, in Bhumika Trust v. Union of India, a bench led by Chief Justice Surya Kant modified that rule by a 2:1 majority. Fresh graduates can apply again for now, and from April 2027 the requirement drops to one year of practice. The remaining two years are replaced by academy training and a law clerkship after selection.

Read the judgment (PDF) →

Advertisement

Case at a glance

  • Case: Bhumika Trust v. Union of India and others, Writ Petition (Civil) No. 1110 of 2025, with review petitions in Writ Petition (Civil) No. 1022 of 1989 (the All India Judges Association case)
  • Citation: 2026 INSC 904
  • Bench: Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justice Augustine George Masih (majority, written by the Chief Justice); Justice K. Vinod Chandran dissented
  • Decided: 21 August 2026
  • What was under review: the Court’s judgment of 20 May 2025, which restored the three-year practice requirement

Phase 1: Recruitment notified up to 31 March 2027

For every Civil Judge (Junior Division) notification issued after the May 2025 judgment and up to 31 March 2027 (para 73):

  1. All law graduates can apply, despite the three-year rule. Because more than a year has passed since the May 2025 judgment, they are deemed to have one year of active practice and need no certificate of practice for that deemed period.
  2. Those selected become “Trainee Judicial Officers” and do one year of intensive training at the State Judicial Academy. This counts as one year of practice.
  3. During training they get a fixed emolument equal to half the pay of a Judicial Magistrate First Class in that State, plus the usual trainee facilities.
  4. Next comes one year of Law Clerkship: six months under a Principal District / District and Sessions Judge or a member of the Higher Judicial Service, then six months under a sitting High Court Judge. This also counts as one year of practice.
  5. Clerkship pay stays the same as during training, with no extra allowance.
  6. After the clerkship, the supervising High Court Judge gives a reasoned evaluation report. If it is satisfactory, the trainee is appointed to the regular post with the regular pay scale.

The Court explained that candidates had been left uncertain about their eligibility for over a year, so it made little sense to apply the full rule to fresh graduates who could not have anticipated it (para 65).

Phase 2: Recruitment notified on or after 1 April 2027

  • Every candidate must have at least one year of actual practice, proved by a certificate of practice (para 74).
  • The certificate will not be issued unless the candidate’s presence and participation in effective judicial proceedings, alongside a senior with at least 10 years’ practice or otherwise, has been recorded under a mechanism the High Courts will prescribe.
  • The application is entertained only with the certificate of one year’s actual practice in the District Courts.
  • Even with that year of practice, selected candidates still do the same one-year academy training and the one-year clerkship (six months under a District Judge, six months under a High Court Judge).

Other directions

  • All notifications already issued after the May 2025 judgment, and all future ones, must follow these directions (para 75).
  • State Governments, in consultation with the High Courts, must amend their rules within three months, and the interim orders stand vacated (para 76).
  • The scheme stays in force for five years, after which its working will be placed before the Court for review (paras 79-80).

The dissent

Justice K. Vinod Chandran disagreed. In his view the review of the “well-considered, well thought out decision of a three-judge bench” prescribing three years’ practice was not imperative, and he stressed the value of courtroom experience before a judicial career.

What it means for you

  • Final-year students and fresh graduates: you can still apply to notifications issued up to 31 March 2027, without a practice certificate.
  • Planning for later exams: for notifications from 1 April 2027, start practice early and make sure your attendance in proceedings is recorded as your High Court prescribes.
  • Everyone selected: expect two years of training and clerkship, at half a JMFC’s pay, before regular posting.

The first big exam under these rules is UP PCS-J 2026 (365 posts). Its advertisement relies on paragraph 73 of this judgment.

Source

Advertisement