If you did not ask for something in your first case, can you ask for it later? Usually not: the rule of constructive res judicata and Order II Rule 2 CPC bar a claim you could and should have made earlier. But in Ashok Kumar v. Central Bank of India, the Supreme Court has drawn the line clearly. The bar applies only to a claim that existed when the first case was filed. A claim that arises later is a fresh cause of action and can be pursued in a fresh case.
Case at a glance
- Case: Ashok Kumar v. Central Bank of India & Ors., Civil Appeal arising out of SLP (C) No. 29916 of 2024
- Citation: 2026 INSC 1242
- Bench: Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Sheel Nagu (judgment by Justice Datta)
- Decided: 18 November 2026
- From: Punjab and Haryana High Court, LPA 1164 of 2024 (decided 9 May 2024)
- Result: High Court order set aside; Bank to pay Rs 5 lakh more in full and final settlement
The facts
- 1991: A Central Bank of India employee filed a writ petition challenging the departmental proceedings against him. He did not claim interest.
- 2007: The High Court allowed his petition, and the Bank’s intra-court appeal was dismissed.
- 2011: The Supreme Court dismissed the Bank’s SLP, and the Bank paid the arrears, more than Rs 42 lakh in all.
- 2015: He filed a second writ petition claiming interest on the arrears for the years of delay.
- 2023-2024: The High Court refused relief, essentially because interest had not been claimed in the first petition.
What the Supreme Court held
1. The bar applies only to claims that existed then
Res judicata, principles analogous to it, and the bar of Order II Rule 2 CPC apply only to a claim that was available when the earlier proceeding was filed (para 20).
2. Delay in payment is a later cause of action
When the first petition was filed in 1991, there were no withheld arrears and no delay to compensate. The claim for interest arose only after the High Court’s order and the Bank’s delayed payment. It “did not arise from the same cause of action which triggered the earlier writ petition” (para 20).
In the Court’s words: “A claim based on a subsequent cause of action cannot be barred by a judgment on a prior cause of action.” (para 20)
3. A fresh case, not a miscellaneous application
A claim for interest needs its own facts to be decided: entitlement, the period of delay and who caused it, and the rate. Such a substantive claim cannot be pushed through a miscellaneous application in a disposed-of case (paras 21-22). A fresh proceeding was the right remedy.
4. Relief
Given the long history, the Court used Article 142 and directed the Bank to pay an additional Rs 5,00,000 within two months, in full and final settlement (para 26).
Constructive res judicata in one minute
- Section 11, Explanation IV, CPC: a matter that might and ought to have been raised as a ground of attack or defence in a former suit is treated as having been directly and substantially in issue in it.
- Order II Rule 2, CPC: a suit must include the whole of the claim arising from a cause of action. Relief omitted without leave of the court cannot be sued for later.
- The test from this case: did the claim exist when the first case was filed? If yes, it is barred. If it arose later, it can be claimed.
Why it matters
- For employees and pensioners: winning reinstatement or arrears does not end your rights. If payment is delayed, interest on the delay is a separate claim.
- For lawyers: claim interest in the first case if it has already accrued. If it accrues later, bring a fresh petition, not a miscellaneous application.
- For AIBE and judiciary aspirants: constructive res judicata (Section 11, Explanation IV) and Order II Rule 2 are tested often; remember the “existed then or arose later” test.



